Hiroshima Watch stopped at the moment of the atomic bomb blast |
Those further away from the epicenter of the blast reported a noiseless flash off pure white light. The flash was so intense, the pattern of women's summer dresses where burned onto their skin, macabre tattoos. The burns sustained were horrifying beyond belief, skin burned black and sloughed off. People reported seeing dead butterflies floating to earth in flames and the outlines of bodies scorched onto paving stones.
After the initial blast a second wave of destruction spread from the epicenter destroying almost everything in it's path, this was followed by a devastating fire storm. Black rain fell from the sky, composed of ash and smoke sucked up into the huge mushroom cloud. People, desperate for water drank this radioactive rain. Days later many died as a direct result of drinking this poison rain.
Soon after the initial bombing, people started to display symptoms of radiation sickness; hair loss, vomiting, massive internal hemorrhaging, necrosis, profuse bleeding from wounds, that could not be abated and eventually death.
The American's chose Hiroshima for a reason. It had been left intact, unlike 67 other Japanese cities that had been fire bombed into ashes, and so would serve as a living laboratory, a chance to study the effects of the Atom bomb on buildings and people. The people of Hiroshima would serve as the guinea pigs in this experiment in mass destruction. Even the American scientists were not prepared for the utter devastation not only of the blast itself but of the radiation sickness that followed. Robert Oppenheimer, one of the physicists that worked on the A - Bomb project was quoted as saying later, "Now I have become death, the destroyer of worlds". He would go on to campaign against the use of Atomic weapons and against the post war escalation of nuclear weapons.
The reasons given for the use of the Atomic bomb were said to avoid an inevitable invasion of the Japanese mainland by the allied forces. True, the Japanese leaders seemed hell bent on self sacrifice rather than surrender, expecting every man woman and child to die defending the honour of the Japanese nation. But would this really have happened? Japan was a nation on the brink of starvation, some reported not having had white rive in over a year. It's people were tired and and broken by an un-winnable war. Germany, Japan's main ally had already surrendered, Russia had declared war on Japan and were preparing for an invasion. It's impossible to say what the outcome of an invasion of the Japanese would have wrought, but the estimate at the time of millions of allied troops being killed in hindsight sounds like an over exaggeration, and so the debate continues on the reason for the use of the A-Bomb. After the bombing of Hiroshima, the Japanese high command refused to the terms of surrender proposed by the allies, and on August the 9th. a second atomic bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. Although the devastation was nothing like that off the Hiroshima bombing, 50,000 people still lost their lives.
The final death total is estimated in the region of a quarter of a million people, most of them civilians. For this alone, the bombings of both Hiroshima and Nagasaki remain a reminder of the real cost of war. Memorials remind us of the suffering and inevitable futility of war in all it's guises, for in war there are no victors.
For further reading, go to John Hersey's book "Hiroshima"
Monday morning quarterbacking at its best. This was a nation that had descended into cannibalism for a means of survival, that was truly believing (courtesy of its government) that death was in fact a desirable alternative to the purported horrors the American army would inflict, and that demonstrated as much by the mass suicides that are a matter of record. No, millions of allied casualties sustained in an attack on the Japanese home islands does NOT seem like an exaggeration. War is an atrocity in its very conception. Once undertaken, all bets are off.
ReplyDeleteThere are no "Marquis of Queensbury" rules.
Good points, well made Andrew...a horror story all round. A
ReplyDeleteSeems like they could have starved the Japanese out, or dropped a bomb on a less populated area for terror value, then waited a bit. (I know, they only had two!) These and other strategies were proposed and ignored then.
ReplyDeleteThe Japanese regime and its army was truly brutal, but it was also encouraged in this by American policy - take no prisoners. Not talked about much, but US GIs routinely shot surrendered Japanese. Naturally, the Japanese were not sanguine about their treatment if they gave up. (Of course, the Japanese didn't take prisoners either...who started it? But consider that US policy in Europe was to distribute propaganda to German troops about how well German POWs were treated.) The A-Bomb was, in part, a logical culmination of US policy.
Finally, while I think the A-Bomb attack is a tremendously important human milestone - and not a good one! - I can't help but think that firebombing Japanese cities made of wood, and using the same on German cities, which resulted in casualties far higher than the two A-Bomb blasts are also instances of the use of 'weapons of mass destruction.'
As Curtis LeMay remarked to Robert McNamara about the raids on Japan, "If we were to lose the war, we'll be tried as war criminals."
Lichanos, I agree about the fire bombings and the carpet bombings of German cities, especially by the RAF under Wing Commander Harris.
ReplyDeleteI always wondered why the Americans didn't drop the A bomb on Iwo Jima as a test, instead of entering into the bloody battle that ensued. Maybe it wasn't ready then. The Pacific campaign was a total bloodbath on all sides, an apocalypse. The Atom bomb probably would've been dropped on Germany if they hadn't surrendered according to John Heresey's book. I read the Curtis Lemay quote...true in my opinion. War is hell as they say. Anthony
"Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds." Robert Oppenheimer after the first test of the atomic bomb. This about sums it up and they still went ahead. Still we won the war! Didn't we?
ReplyDelete